Is transnational estoppel really transnational or is it just the application of domestic law?

1. Can the application of issue estoppel be reconciled with Article V(1)(e) of the New York Convention insofar as it confers a discretion on the enforcing court to recognise and
enforce an award when the seat or another enforcement court has set it aside, or found it not binding etc.?
2. Does any estoppel arise pursuant to the forum’s public policy under Article V(2)(b) against re-litigation of a matter?
3. Can the forum find that a transnational estoppel on an issue arises from a prior decision of a jurisdiction (e.g Switzerland) that does not recognise the concept of issue estoppel?
4. Is / should the nature of the “issue” in question be relevant to the analysis (e.g. should state immunity be dealt with differently)?
5. What are the proper limits to the operation of issue estoppel under English law given the recent Supreme Court decision in Skatteforvalingen v MCML [2026] UKSC 19?

In considering these issues the panel will discuss a number of relevant recent decisions from the UK and abroad.

Date:01/12/2026
Chair:Duncan Matthews KC - Twenty Essex
Panellists:HE Justice Mark Pelling - DIFC Courts
The Hon Steven Rares KC - Arbitrator (Australia)
Liisa Lahti, Barrister - 3 Verulam Buildings
Christopher Smith KC, Barrister - Essex Court Chambers
Venue:Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLP
90 High Holborn
London
WC1V 6LJ
Time:2.30pm - 4.00pm
CPD Points:1.5 CPD points